Customer Reviews (107 Total)
I love lamp.
August 31, 2017
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
And Burley. I have come to the conclusion that I generally just like the bite of Burley. Sippin it slow or chuggin like a freight train, I love it. When I opened the box I recieved today from smokingpipes, I was immediately greeted with a smell I cou... Read More
ldnt put my finger on. Opened the bag and this blend just shook my hand. The Burley mixed with this deertongue was crazy. And, I had never smelled deertongue until I opened the bag. Awesome. Scooped and gravity filled a cob. Burns a bit warm, so I slow rolled it. Some think this is mellow, but for me, the burley is like a bear pawing at you, whilst also medicating your wounds with this herbal, vanilla type salve. Damn. This is going to sound as interesting as my review, but I judge tobaccy' on two grounds. 1., the taste. 2., how it smells residually in my moustache. Weird? Maybe. But this smell that sticks to you, is one of the finest things I have ever experienced. Reminds me of a cross between the old Teaberry gum, and angel farts. If you arent a fan of Burley, hold off on this. BUT, if you want to sac up and embody the soul of one of the most sweet voices of all time, and enjoy a bit of a challenge, this is it. Oh yeah, the room note is just unreal. Get at it or dont. There is no middle ground with this blend. Personally, Im sold on it. Read Less
My favorite
August 11, 2017
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner 2oz
Crooner is my absolute favorite pipe tobaccos that I've come across! The tin note on this is extraordinary and is a smell i always thoroughly enjoy every time i crack open the tin and gets only better once it is lit up! It's one of those tobaccos whi... Read More
ch goes perfectly with a relaxing evening with some friends as you enjoy their company and reminisce by a nicely lit fire. It tastes phenomenal and is a tobacco i will always come back for more of throughout my life! Read Less
Would you like to swing on a star...?
May 05, 2018
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner 2oz
What a pleasant surprise this is. I have sampled a few blends with deer tongue and found them "interesting", but not something to write home about. But this is the exception, probably due to its utter simplicity.
I see some other reviews that peopl... Read More
e didn't like the fact that the burley can bite. Yup, that's true, mild tasting burley (which this is) can really bite you if you attack it. And the vitamin N content can sneak up and whack you over the head also. but if this one is biting you then check your technique, because I found no bite whatsoever.
And I read a couple who didn't like the deer tongue taste, okay I can understand that, I don't care for Lakeland essence. In fact if the Lakeland blends tasted like this I would smoke them and enjoy them... they don't, I don't. .. 'nuff said.
This won't be my all day smoke, maybe not even an everyday smoke, but I think I will making sure to have it around for a great change of pace smoke. Read Less
Now you has jazz!
April 10, 2018
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
"Crooner" is my #1. This will be a delight for any Burley fan. Especially since the cube cut burley comes straight out of the tin/bag at the perfect smoking moisture. It is very easy to keep lit. But the real magic for me, is the Deertongue... Read More
. I can't get enough of it. Some say it gives a hint of vanilla. Others such as myself, say it's indescribable. Something I've never experienced before. The room note isn't bad, but is not like a aromatic. Very retro "grandpa's pipe" smelling tobacco, with a hint of cigarette, due to the burley. Which I actually love. It is strong. It does have a good Vitamin "N" hit. It does give a burley bite, but not in a bad way. The tin note is very pleasing and reminds me a lot of a box of raisin bran cereal. I'm a fan of Bing and I'm a fan of "Crooner". Get this and you'll be crooning in no time! Read Less
To Each His Own
April 15, 2014
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
Crooner isn't for everyone, but if you like burley and want something a bit more interesting, Crooner is it. I'm impressed with the quality, strength, and easy smoking of the cubed burley. As far as the deer tongue, when properly dried, it adds a s... Read More
ubtle and enjoyable scent and flavor. I would describe that flavor as jasmine tea with milk and honey. I only have an ounce of Crooner, but will surely stock it among a very select few aromatics on my shelf. If you order Crooner ask for double baging and keep it away from other tobaccos as the fresh deer tongue is very pungent. In my opinion, Crooner is most enjoyable when it is quite dry and the scent of the deer tongue has mellowed. Read Less
Strong yet smooth
February 20, 2018
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
I just love the spicy aroma of this blend. I really have found that burleys suit me, but this one is special. The taste is mellow yet very flavorful. Mr. Crosby thank you for this blend!
New favorite
October 14, 2017
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
This is a blend I will now buy byour the pound.As usual when I find a blend I want to stock up on it goes out of stock
The memory of the nose
February 07, 2018
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
I love this blend, but since I'm a new pipe smoker, I decided I won't give any 1 stars or 5 stars until my palate develops. This tobacco smells like a camp I use to attend every summer in my youth. That's a strange way to say it smells like beach, wo... Read More
ods, and sea touched air. I love the taste as well, which shocked me because I'm definitely finding out that I love English blends (mainly I'm a latikia hound). This blend is not very nuanced, but the deertongue really adds to the burley. I will definitely get this as a change of pace tobacco! Read Less
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
I'm a cigar smoker delving into the world of pipe smoking, and when I immerse myself into something, I go all out. This blend is utterly delicious. Bought on a whim because I am a fan of Bing Crosby, I'm about to order a pound after writing this re... Read More
view. I have a few knock around cobs, but I had to smoke this in my savinelli because Bing crosby = class. It tastes amazing, nice and strong with a unique room note. (Maybe it's the deer tounge?) I DO agree with another reviewer that maybe it's cube cut a little too small, ended up sucking some through the mouthpiece. Read Less
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner 2oz
As soon as I open the tin, I am greeted by the aroma of cinnamon and spices. Truly compelling tin note. Stays lit for me well with very few re-lights, and is bursting with flavor. By far, the best room note in my opinion. The nic hit is strong and co... Read More
mes all at once. It doesn't sneak up on you. Will be buying in bulk from now on. Read Less
Strong yet smooth
February 20, 2018
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
I just love the spicy aroma of this blend. I really have found that burleys suit me, but this one is special. The taste is mellow yet very flavorful. Mr. Crosby thank you for this blend!
My favorite deer tongue blend
March 08, 2017
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
I have tried all the C&D deer tongue blends and this is my favorite by far. It smells great (my wife loves it) and it burns clean down to a fine ash. My only complaint is the nicotine strength is to much for me so I have to smoke small bowls an... Read More
d carefully. I am considering mixing this with some Gentleman Caller to make it less strong so I can enjoy more of it. If you didn't already know, dedicate a pipe to deer tongue as it will forever ghost your pipe. Read Less
Just For Fun
August 03, 2022
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
I recently acquired a Savinelli Bing Crosby pipe and ordered this tobacco just to try in this pipe. It's not the best tobacco but I smoke the pipe and this tobacco when I'm golfing. I should stop playing golf and just go home and enjoy my pipe!
Bing knew what he was doing.
December 19, 2021
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner 2oz
Has a kind of honeysuckle flavor to it. Definitely floral and sweet, but not overdone. This one is almost like an incredibly natural aromatic. Definitely unique and worth a try.
10 Years After
November 18, 2020
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
10+ years ago, I purchased a pound of Crooner directly from Cornell & Diehl. Back then, Craig Tarler was still handling phone calls at C&D personally. Upon receiving that bulk pound, I discovered large cubes of nut brown Burley (all uniform i... Read More
n color) that were accompanied by light green flecks of Deertongue. Those were the days.
It took practice getting a pipeful of Crooner properly packed; simply loading the bowl full of cubes was foolhardy. But in time, I discovered that placing a few whole cubes at the bottom and packing the remaining two-thirds of the bowl with the mixture well rubbed- I discovered that Crooner rewarded the effort with a pleasant smoke that was spicy, but burned consistently and resisted clogging, due to the whole cubes placed at the bottom.
Unfortunately, the consistency of the Crooner is no longer what it once was (or at least what I received was a far cry from the old Crooner.) If you’re not familiar with what cubed Burley looks like, I would have told you (years ago) to go to your local drug store and pick up a bag of “Half & Half.” Despite what the description of Crooner might lead one to believe, it is no longer what I would call “cubed” or even cube-cut for that matter. The 8 ounces of bulk Crooner I received for my birthday was what I’d call “granulated” at best. It’s still flavorful and exotic (due to the Deertongue) but it’s no longer capable of providing the same experience because there are no cubes of Burley left to speak of.
If you’re a fan of Burley and find yourself fascinated by Deertongue in tobacco blends, it’s still a must-have. But if, like me, your last batch came from the hands of Mr. Tarler himself- you’re in for a shock. All I can say is- smoke slowly, pack your pipe lightly and tamp carefully or else... Read Less
Smells Like Alfalfa Hay
April 13, 2020
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
The cube cut burley is fermented and offers some sharpness. The Deertongue contributes a sweet alfalfa hay aroma, but doesn't alter the taste of the mixture. If you like burley and want a fresh, grassy incense or alfalfa hay room note, this will d... Read More
o it. Nicotine is moderate. Read Less
History
September 09, 2019
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
I enjoy the lack of depth. Seems to be less stressful sometimes. I seldom have to time to sit and dig into the depths of more complex tobaccos. Burley, Deeretounge and a slight hint of vanilla (however that happens) is just what I need for a fast pac... Read More
ed existence. And somehow the story helps with the experience. I croon all day, everyday. Read Less
Best deer tongue to date.
September 03, 2018
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner 2oz
This is an excellent tasting blend, Burley does burn quickly, but very enjoyable.
A most curious Coumarin
June 21, 2018
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
First, the tobacco is high quality, high nicotine and a perfect humidity. The chocolate pepper notes of the burley ride shotgun to the Coumarins in the deer tongue. Similar to vanilla but more comparable to sweet grass, Hierochloe odorata, used in P... Read More
olish vodka, and as a smudge by Native Americans. Very inspiring, and bold. Read Less
Crooner
November 01, 2017
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner 2oz
Mild to strong barely character is clear, so not too complex. Deertongue leaves a pleasant taste in the pallet and an aroma that reminds you of an old wooden furnished house. In short, it is a pleasant all day smoking.
Simple & Pleasant
October 12, 2017
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
Like Bing Crosby, it's unique but simple. Because deertongue is an herb—not a type of tobacco—I was very interested to smoke this, as no other blends I know of utilize herbs. Tin notes of hay, alfalfa, and plain Burley set it apart from all others. T... Read More
he flavor is plain Burley with a grassy herb twist and no more; its casing rounds it out but is ultimately very light. The deertongue is not too strong in flavor or content. A note of vanilla has been mentioned by others but I don't taste it. There's a definite "Old World" feel to Crooner. Imagine Carter Hall with a lighter casing and a smell and a note of an alfalfa-like herb. There's a hint of cigarette here too, but it's not crazy. Because of deertongue, the room note is also unique, but most non-smokers typically don't like it; the tin note is a different story. It's easy to see why fresh deertongue plants were used as air fresheners by the native Americans and settlers centuries ago. I'd imagine natives and the early settlers would've been familiar with a combination like this. Overall, I like Crooner, but I prefer more depth—it's a bit too plain for my everyday smoking preferences. With all that said, it's absolutely worth a try if the aforementioned characteristics sound good to you. As with all of my reviews, I'll rewrite it when I smoke more over time, and also after I smoke C&D's other deertongue blend, Gentleman Caller. Read Less
I really like this...a lot!
March 11, 2024
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner 2oz
I just received a tin of Gentleman Caller and I also received about a 1.5oz sample of Crooner today from a youtube creator. I just had a bowl of Crooner, in a new Old Dominion "The Dutchman" pipe. And I really like the stuff (granted, first bowl); bo... Read More
th its aroma and its taste. I have added its link to my upcoming list of blends to order...and I will also order more "Gentleman Caller" in hopes the Deer Tongue and its flavor is just as good as that of Crooner. I will likely only burn these blends in my assorted clay pipes; following the warning of Deer Tongue ghosting pipes. But it is worth having more of this and Gent Caller on hand to either burn from time to time or even daily. I recommend trying this one, or the other; Gent Caller. But save some Crooner for me. *Update* I bumped my Star rating today from 4.5 to 5 Stars. I ordered two pounds of Crooner because I gotta have this daily. Read Less
Perfect "sometimes" option for burley folks
July 10, 2021
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
I'm a huge burley fan, straight up or in blends. This is a really good option when I'm after a little bit of pizzazz. I've read it has some ghosting qualities, so I've only smoked it in one pipe, which coincidentally is a Savinelli Bing's Favorite. ... Read More
As an added benefit, I can now sing in three octaves. Read Less
Croon a little blend for me, Bing
July 02, 2020
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
I got this C&D blend specifically to smoke in the several Savinelli “Bing’s Favorite” pipes I have—yah, I know, corny as Kansas, what the heck. Overall, the blend is gentle (not a big fan of Burley) and the deertongue does give a nice upstate New... Read More
York meadow-y taste and nose. Room note is unobtrusive.
That last statement is the crux of my problem with Crooner. Like Der Bingle…Crooner is just too laid back. See—I’m one of those Lat-forward English blend folks. In abject glorification of Sherlock Holmes, I smoke Latakia straight up, none of this tippy-toeing around as blending tobacco.
Crooner is good and I’ll recommend it to anyone. No bite and stays lit nicely. It’s so…Holiday Inn-ish.
Philistine-like it may be, I’ve decided to work up a blend using Crooner as the predominate base and add a goodly portion of Perique—thinking along the lines of a 2:1 Crooner/Perique ratio.
Giving Crooner 4.5—great blend, just sorta loses some tenths of points on the dismount. Read Less
Bing Bing Bing She’s A Winner!!!!
February 13, 2020
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
She smells great even before she starts cooking. But when you walk in the room you can smell her perfume. The more I have of her the more I want. She makes me feel amazing. She tastes so good. Like no other. I can spend all day with her and into the ... Read More
night. I compare all the others to her. Read Less
That deer tongue is too much
February 01, 2019
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner 2oz
The cut is strange, almost like powder, the smell is nauseating, the flavor i cant describe and god bless what a mistake
Nostalgia in a bowl.
June 14, 2018
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
I'm not a big fan of Burley forward blends, but I have to admit to liking this one. I've tried all of the Deertongue blends (I think) and believe this is the best of them...it's certainly the most popular. Even still, it's a love it or hate it tobacc... Read More
o. I think what I like about it lies in its simplicity. You have a great cube-cut Burely (with dreamlike mechanics) and just the right amount of natural condimental Deertongue and that's it! It's no surprise the Burley steals the show. It is a full-bodied Burley that's creamy to a fault, but the Deertongue adds a balanced sweetness that is crucial to the flavor of Crooner. My first time having Crooner I went on a binge and didn't want anything else, that's how good it is! Eventually, it was just too much Burley too often for me and I had to ween myself off, but I do still enjoy a bowl from time to time. Some guys claim this is there go-to blend and it's not hard to see why. And, no, you don't have to smoke Crooner from a Savinelli Bing's Favorite, but hey, if you got one.... UPDATE (2022): Crooner has become a yearly regular for me around the holidays. Since I wrote this review it has became my Christmas Day blend of choice. There's just something about the taste and aroma that takes me back to my grandmother's kitchen on Christmas morning. Read Less
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner 2oz
I think it may be the deer tongue, but I cant swing this stuff. It packs and smokes fine, but that soapy deer tongue is just not for my palate and I love lakelands.
I gave it 3 stars because it is a quality blend that many seem to love and my disr... Read More
egard for it is taste-based only, so I didn't wanna affect it's rating too dramatically. Read Less
Pleasantly surprised!
March 26, 2018
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
I am Starting to become a fan of Burley Blends. I really enjoy “Haunted Bookshop “ Old Joe Krantz, “Aged Burley Flake”. This is first and foremost a Burly Blend, I really enjoy the Cube Cut for packing and smoking. The nuttyness of the burly mixed w... Read More
ith a vanilla “like” sweetness that pops in and says hello from time to time. I had never had Deertongue before in a Blend and was a bit worried I would not like it, I’m glad I gave it a try. I’ve been really enjoying many relaxing smokes with this Blend. Definitely worth a try! Read Less
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner 2oz
This has been my go-to tobacco for many months. Nutty burly. Fragrant deer tongue
Glad i discovered this blend
June 28, 2024
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
So i had an itch for a deer tongue blend for my cellar and i havent had a DT blend in a good while, so i ordered this thinking this was the deer tongue blend i used to have, i smoked some and instantly realized this was different, well a few bowls in... Read More
i really like this stuff, after finding the old jar i had the other stuff was in, forgot it was engine#382 😂 this stuff is great though so im glad i got a pound before it went out of stock, also recently got a pound of engine#382 cause thats the one i originanilly meant to get, but im happy all around , these DT blends are great, ALTHOGH i dont know that these would be the best for a rookie, sorry for the long review but this stuff is great for a burley lover 👍 all you need to know really Read Less
Glad i discovered this blend
June 28, 2024
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
So i had an itch for a deer tongue blend for my cellar and i havent had a DT blend in a good while, so i ordered this thinking this was the deer tongue blend i used to have, i smoked some and instantly realized this was different, well a few bowls in... Read More
i really like this stuff, after finding the old jar i had the other stuff was in, forgot it was engine#382 😂 this stuff is great though so im glad i got a pound before it went out of stock, also recently got a pound of engine#382 cause thats the one i originanilly meant to get, but im happy all around , these DT blends are great, ALTHOGH i dont know that these would be the best for a rookie, sorry for the long review but this stuff is great for a burley lover 👍 all you need to know really Read Less
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
I have given up trying to articulate why I like this blend so much. I even tried to talk myself out of liking it. Not sure why. I used to not reach for it often. Too busy with the manly Latakia bombs and snobby Vapers I guess but I have finally decid... Read More
ed that I just like it. Never had a bad bowl of Crooner. I will always have some on hand. Read Less
Very nice burley
March 22, 2024
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner 2oz
My first burley, and I'm impressed. Not harsh, as I was led to expect from a local expert.
My only complaint: after smoking several bowls of Bing Crosby's blend, I stll can't sing worth a damn! Buh buh buh boo, indeed!
Crooner PLUS
November 18, 2023
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
Just received my order of Crooner bulk which is my favorite Burley-based tobacco. ALSO in the order was a bit of Latakia, which I order for the express purpose, fiendish may it be judged, to mix 50/50 with the Crooner. Folks, if you are a lover of Cr... Read More
ooner, AND hanker for a touch of an English blend twist, do try the Crooner/Lat matchup. Crooner stands up nicely to the Lat and the Lat plays nicely, lending a subtle boost. Enjoy... Read Less
Crooner PLUS
November 18, 2023
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
Just received my order of Crooner bulk which is my favorite Burley-based tobacco. ALSO in the order was a bit of Latakia, which I order for the express purpose, fiendish may it be judged, to mix 50/50 with the Crooner. Folks, if you are a lover of Cr... Read More
ooner, AND hanker for a touch of an English blend twist, do try the Crooner/Lat matchup. Crooner stands up nicely to the Lat and the Lat plays nicely, lending a subtle boost. Enjoy... Read Less
What a shame
September 18, 2023
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner 2oz
Through the bag, it smells like herbal tea. opening the bag, the dominant smell is somewhere between hay and moist wood chips, with that herbal tea note still poking out from underneath. The smoke starts smooth and solid: An inoffensive nice burley, ... Read More
smooth and earthy. The deertongue seems to add a mild note that accents the flavor quite nicely. But soon an odd coolness begins appearing in a spot or two of the mouth, and the accent becomes slightly off. Still, not really bad, a decent smoke that is just a little different. But when the pipe is done, an aftertaste emerges. A slightly bitter taste I find unpleasant, a little planty, a little pharmaceutical. This aftertaste lingers and overshadows the enjoyable time spent smoking the tobacco. It's not for everyone, and it's not for me. Read Less
Baffled by this
May 16, 2023
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner 2oz
I tried it on a whim and stumbled upon a new favorite.
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
Really nice blend. Very mellow. Room note is awesome. Bag note was mild and sweet. Got some earthy burley but couldn't really pick up on the deertongue that much. (Not as much as some make out anyways.) I noticed that when the deertongue caught fire ... Read More
it fizzled and sparked like gunpowder or fireworks fuse? Weird. Anyone else notice that? Came decently dry. This is a good smoke for just kicking back and relaxing. Not harsh or bitter. Read Less
Bing was a man of taste!
March 04, 2023
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
This blend astounded me. The tin note wafted from the box vefore i even got it opened. It smelled a bit like elmos reserve snuff. The sweet and pungent aromas were prominent though the first third of the bowl and gave way to the smooth and mellow yet... Read More
grassy burley flavor. The bottom of the bowls taste was remeniscent of haunted bookshop with zero bite. 10/10 will be ordering again! Read Less
Very unique
January 08, 2023
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner 2oz
Forewarning, this will ghost a pipe. I really liked the honey/rasin taste of this tobacco. Its super unique and interesting. I would almost say it tastes and smells something like the way Taylor's Pride chewing tobacco smells (which is a good thing ... Read More
to me). I have dedicated a pipe to it. Read Less
Quality but not for me
December 26, 2022
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner 2oz
Overall not my favorite, the quality is there, and in general I'm not a huge burly fan, and the deer tongue will ghost a pipe, I only use it in my cob and sparingly
Not Too Bad..
October 23, 2022
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner 2oz
It’s not a bad blend - but a favorite blend? Not quite to my palate,
Great tribute to the crooner Crosby
August 15, 2022
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
I was impressed with aroma and even burn of this tobacco. I didn't have to relight it at all. I wish it had more taste, but overall a great mix.
An Absolute Favorite
May 21, 2022
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
It isn't really a secret that C&D is to Burley what Col. Sanders is/was to chicken, However, this stuff is amazing. Now, two other Favorites for me are OJK and Five Brothers - I like Burley! But,this stuff has a sweet, yet Herbal (think oriental)... Read More
and sometimes near Floral note... but I'd say mostly it's a sweet, almost woody note, again, akin to Turkish/Oriental. It's cube cut, so you know it behaves well. I've had it in cobs, briar, BRYLON, clay... this stuff is a winner. Read Less
What can I say?
March 13, 2022
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner 2oz
This blend is delightful, starts off nice and smooth, halfway in you get that zing from the burly, and in comes the deer tongue, it has a nice floral bite of lavender, with a bit of honey, and is so delicious, and a really nice finish.
The tin note ... Read More
is amazing too, the smell of the deer tongue is like that of wildflowers, Jasmine, fresh hay, but so nice you want to eat it instead of smoking it.
I can't get enough of it, I am definitely ordering more next time!
It tastes as one person best described it, jasmine tea with milk and honey, can't get enough, and after having smoked it for a while you get used to it, they blend together nicely, and the Deer tongue comes through with a bit of a minty/ light menthol note, for a smooth finish, after the burley has came in bold but smooth. Read Less
Somewhat bland
March 10, 2022
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner 2oz
I love burleys. As far as burleys go this isn’t bad, but it’s not something I’d recommend to anyone or buy again myself. The addition of the deertongue is pleasant but the blend is pretty bland. It honestly reminded me a lot of Carter Hall, the same ... Read More
flavor profile, just more muted and a little more bland. I much prefer Carter Hall as far as these flavors go. Read Less
Count your blessings (instead of sheep)
November 01, 2021
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner 2oz
First, for complete transparency, the only reason I bought this tobacco is because I'm a big Bing Crosby fan. That said, I had no idea what to really expect from this blend; Bing's blend. After smoking a few bowls, I find it interesting and pleasan... Read More
t. A nice change of pace for me. Nothing is overpowering, the flavor is nice, the room note is nice. Behaves well in the bowl. Give it a try if you’re looking for something new or different. Read Less
Love at first whiff!
September 07, 2021
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
This is my first review on this site, but one I felt compelled to write! This is an all time favorite for me and not just because I am a huge Bing fan. That is, admittedly, why I decided to try this blend, but the tin aroma and taste are what keep me... Read More
coming back. You simply cannot find anything to compare. It is absolutely one of my favorite smells! WARNING this blend will ghost a pipe big time, so a dedicated pipe is necessary. Awesome for the holidays or outdoor smoke in the cool evening air. Read Less
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
Received mine today. Very well pleased with this tobacco. No bite, smoothe relaxing smoke, burns clean and even. One of the best I have smoked in awhile. Will be a repeat customer on this one.
Perfect "sometimes" option for burley folks
July 10, 2021
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
I'm a huge burley fan, straight up or in blends. This is a really good option when I'm after a little bit of pizzazz. I've read it has some ghosting qualities, so I've only smoked it in one pipe, which coincidentally is a Savinelli Bing's Favorite. ... Read More
As an added benefit, I can now sing in three octaves. Read Less
Interesting
April 20, 2021
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner 2oz
If you like Haunted Bookshop you will probably enjoy Crooner. This blend includes the most deertongue I have seen in any popular blend so far. If you are not a fan of deertongue you will not like this blend one bit. I love it.
Hello Mellow
April 17, 2021
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner 2oz
Ah Crooner, such a relaxing blend. Cant get enough of this sweet herb. More please :)
like meeting a legend
April 13, 2021
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner 2oz
So i read the story, have no way to validate it and i am good with that. Opening the blend, it almost has a nutmeg, warm smell. The different cuts i had never seen before was fascinating. As soon as i lit the blend in my NOS Ropp, i was greeted as... Read More
if by an old friend. It drew well the room note was nice, nutmeg and other spice, the nuttiness of the burley. To me, i would consider some blends as complete like Peterson's Royal yacht. This is the first mix of different leafs that i would say is absolutely complete. This to me is as legendary as the Crooner and his songs. "Wrap your troubles in dreams" of this tobacco Read Less
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner 2oz
I like Bing and I like this tobacco. It isn’t over the top or super fancy but it does what it does very well. Its old fashioned, reliable, and a hard worker. It has a very pleasant tin that smells slightly like apricots. The nicotine hit is nice. I f... Read More
ind the blend of burley and deer tongue to be exceptional. This may be my new all day smoke. The tobacco burns down to a fine white ash. Excellent for developing cake. If you are looking for a fine burley blend then I would 100% recommend this to you. Read Less
Gingerbread
March 25, 2021
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
I’m a novice pipe smoker but here’s my first try at a review. The initial notes upon opening are of raisin and maybe some brown sugar. Has a nice taste while smoking, smooth but with a little bit of bite, but overall very nice.I was told that it smel... Read More
led like gingerbread, which is never a bad thing. I’ll definitely be stocking up on some more of this, maybe store some to see how it ages. Read Less
It's different
February 25, 2021
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner 2oz
Bummed a bowl from a friend and liked it so much I got a few tins for myself. Will be a good rotational mix for me.
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner 2oz
I didn’t know what to make of the funky tin note but surprisingly this is a very cool smooth smoke. Highly recommended and I’ll purchase more!
Bing Lives On, In Your Ears and If You’re Lucky, Your Pipe Bowl
October 30, 2020
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
Bing Crosby lives forever through his films and of course his music, especially surfacing every Christmas season, but few know that his spirit will also endure through the generations with this resurrected burley blend. For some of his closest friend... Read More
s provided to Cornell & Diehl this recipe of Bing’s all-day favorite blend, and we know C&D isn’t going anywhere anytime soon.
The cube cut format ensures Crooner smokes easy and uniform down to its ashy end. The addition of the Deertongue herb (certainly not a common blending ingredient) is what makes it rich and unique, as C&D delivers a pleasantly pungent room note and a flavor both woodsy and nutty (with the burley) and fused with, via the Deertongue, vanilla and something faintly buttery, or of buttermilk.
Like so many old-school Irish-Americans and Irishmen of his generation, Bing enjoyed a tobacco pipe. But he was one step further in that he was truly a passionate pipester, and so many photos through the decades captured him puffing away at so many pipes. I like to think that when that heart attack felled him on that golf course in Spain in 1977, he was puffing this very blend in—of course—one of his long-shanked Canadian smokers.
In every smoke session with this timeless blend, my thoughts return to that timeless crooner, his voice as strong and rich as his favorite tobacco! 5.0 stars. Read Less
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
Not a bad blend if you like Burley and deertongue, because that’s obviously all you’re getting here. It’s not bad, but I prefer Gentleman Caller.
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
This blend tends to dry out quickly, and for me, at least, needs a shot or two from the spray bottle before loading in the pouch. When smoked too dry...no flavor. But when the moisture content is just right,(a pinch barely hangs together, VOILA!!) in... Read More
stant tobacco bliss. Read Less
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
This blend tends to dry out quickly, and for me, at least, needs a shot or two from the spray bottle before loading in the pouch. When smoked too dry...no flavor. But when the moisture content is just right,(a pinch barely hangs together, VOILA!!) in... Read More
stant tobacco bliss. Read Less
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
This blend tends to dry out quickly, and for me, at least, needs a shot or two from the spray bottle before loading in the pouch. When smoked too dry...no flavor. But when the moisture content is just right,(a pinch barely hangs together, VOILA!!) in... Read More
stant tobacco bliss. Read Less
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
This is the first tobacco my wife has ever enjoyed smelling. Every new tin, jar or bag I bring home, I offer it up for her to take a sniff and usually she wrinkles her nose and says something about old smelly feet or rotten cheese or some other crea... Read More
tive adjectives. Anything wife-approved is good as far as I am concerned. But it doesn't stop there with this one. This was my first deer tongue experience and it didn't disappoint. I can't quite put my finger on what it is... some have said it's vanilla flavor, like jasmin tea with milk and honey, cinnamon and spices... To me it's a little of all that. Herbaceous for sure! From the first sip to the last it is enjoyable, and will be the top 3 in my rotation for a good while. Read Less
Just Let Gravity Do Its Job
June 14, 2020
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
No hassle here. Just perfect tobacco pipe mechanics when you gravity pack and put it to the torch. Flavor is all Deertongue all the way. I smoke for nicotine, mostly. It has to taste good, though. And, this one does that. Mechanics - check. Flavor - ... Read More
check. Nic-hit - check. Good stuff. Read Less
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
Be careful, this could get an occasional bad rap as it ships pretty dry. I spread it out in a big salad bowl and hit with distilled water. Must it pretty good so a pinch barely hangs together, and voila...Here comes that rich burley flavor.
Weird, In a Good Way
June 04, 2020
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner 2oz
I've been curious about this blend since I started smoking a pipe. When I saw C & D was on sale, I figured I'd give it a go. It's got a unique smell. I keep smelling cinnamon and other baking spices. I like the smell. It was the perfect mois... Read More
ture, the cut is fun and easy to work with. It packs well, takes the flame well, and smokes cool and dry. It's got an interesting taste, but all in all, it's fairly enjoyable. It's making me curious about other deertongue blends. Not sure if I'd buy this again, or keep it in the cellar, but that could very easily change. Read Less
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner 2oz
I couldn't wait to try this once it arrived. Opening the tin I was greeted by what I can only describe as fresh baked cinnamon raisin bread. The charring light was semi sweet nutty Burley with a slight vanilla taste in the background. As the bowl pro... Read More
gressed it developed into what I can only describe as pure bliss. Semi sweet, vanilla like and good old nutty Burley. The room note is almost that of a flavored cigar, but very pleasant and light. I'm on my 6th bowl and the more I smoke it, the more I love it. This one's going to be in my rotation for sure. Read Less
...Dreaming of a White Christmas
April 28, 2020
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
I wanted to like this blend a lot more then I actually did. Bing Crosby brings to mind the Holiday season and this blend was no different for me. It has warm flavors of chocolate and a kind of cinnamon taste as well. I smoked two bowls and decided to... Read More
cellar it until the winter when warm flavors were wanted for colder weather. Read Less
Perfect for Fishing
April 09, 2020
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
I have never considered myself a Burley guy, but this has turned me around. Smooth yet spicy. The major player other than a nice spice is a nutty flavor. It is a very creamy smoke. There is also an almost bakers spice to it. I can't pin point the dee... Read More
r tounge, to me it all tastes like tobacco. Perfect for sipping on the river! Read Less
Coconut and more coconut
February 03, 2020
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
Out of the pouch it smells of coconut. Light up and it tastes of coconut. Quite smooth but bland. I normally love deer tongue but something seems to be missing here.
Near perfect
January 27, 2020
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
I cannot attest to how close this is to Bing Crosby's personal blend--seems like he would have had it blended at Kramers, very near his home. But it is an exceptional burley blend. The cube cut is perfect and the taste is great--subtle sweetness ... Read More
and solid tobacco flavor. Burns slow with no bite. Read Less
Bada Bing!!!
October 30, 2019
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
Wow , this stuff is great.. my first ever dance with deertongue.. 5 stars.. they say deertongue tastes like vanilla.. well I’m not getting that at all, more of a blast of Nuts n Honey when sipped as if you lived in a beehive covered in nuts..,followe... Read More
d by A very sweet taste on the tongue and a subtle hint of mint/menthol in the nose on the end after a retrohale. I think that is the mystery note everyone is talking about.. Doesn’t seem to bite much if at all.. then there’s the nic hit.. hello!! And the party just started..tobacco is like grape nuts so pack lightly and use gravity/ trickle method.
Gonna stock up on this as I think it just became my new No.1 everyday smoke. Cheers on a tobacco well done! Read Less
love it
September 26, 2019
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
luv it
Bing’s choice
April 24, 2019
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner 2oz
Bing knew what he was doing when he came up with this blend. I tried this about 10 yrs ago. I didn’t like it, as a tobacco snob was probably my reason to reach a snap decision. I’ve included the old classics in my rotation. I love burly as much as La... Read More
takia. I find this blend to be very mild, no bite and cool burning. I recommend this blend to the burley lover. Read Less
Good Stuff
March 22, 2019
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
I ordered a variety of burley blends and included a couple ounces of this. Turned out to be my favorite of the bunch. I burned through it in a couple of days and followed up with an order for a pound of it. I smoke an ass ton (Imperial Ass Tons to... Read More
be precise.) and I usually smoke Tabac Manil Semois. I kind of get the feeling that it is going to go away so I figured I might want to find a backup. I kind of wish it wasnt named after Bing Crosby, who from what I understand was actually kind of a d-bag, but what can you do? Anyway, I quite enjoy this tobacco and find it to be a nice counterpoint to Semois. Read Less
Much better than I expected
March 22, 2019
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
I'm not usually a fan of big Burley blends because they are usually reminiscent of cigarettes. The Burley in Crooner is high quality, obviously cured properly, with care. The deer tongue is quite evident in Crooner although not as conspicuous as in ... Read More
C&D's New Market although it is more visually present in Crooner. This is, honestly, the first full Burley blend that I can say that I actually like. You have to smoke it slow or it will develop cigarette-like characteristics, but if you go easy, the Burley is nutty, with cocoa overtones that are complemented by the vanilla notes of the deer tongue. Smellwise, this stuff won't make you many friends but when it comes to friends, my goal is quality over quantity. Read Less
Please sir, may I have some more?
March 14, 2019
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner 2oz
Burley by itself is ok, deer tongue by itself is very pungent. However when added together something wonderful and exciting happens. The smell reminds of a dessert I had when I was a small child, and is absolutely amazing. My only problem is I didn't... Read More
order enough. Read Less
Very bold burley with vanilla room note
February 11, 2019
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
Kinda harsh by itself but add some unflavored cavendish or a pinch of sweet Virginia and it smooths out the hot burley. Love the Deertongue / Burley aroma and med-high strength. Just needs a filler of mild leaf added IMHO
Sweet O'Malley
January 27, 2019
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner 2oz
So I've been on a kick lately trying recreations of classic actors blends. So far this is my favorite. incredible rich flavor and smoothness. I will be buying more tins this.
Fantastic
January 25, 2019
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
As stated, you will love or hate this blend most likely. I love it and it is a daily for me.Nice when you can find a blend you love and are able to buy it in bulk
Pleasant
January 24, 2019
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
A decent cube cut burley blend mild smoking, tasty but...would benefit from more deer tongue. This flavoring agent isn’t apparent to my nose or taste buds...maybe that’s the intent. I was hoping for a more apparent taste or smell. The blend is OK as ... Read More
is but in my opinion lacking the extra that should be there with the deer tongue. Maybe Bing’s taste was more sensitive or refined. I like his music and his tobacco taste is admirable but just a bit weak for me. Read Less
Interesting if nothing else
December 28, 2018
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
The deertongue makes this smell like interesting cigarettes. There is a vanilla-like flavor to it, like actual vanilla, not vanilla flavored things. The nic was pretty high and I got a caramel type flavor very occasionally.
True tobacco flavor with a lady pleasing roomnote
December 14, 2018
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
Just got another 8oz... a little too heady by itself, i add a 1.75oz pouch of Captain Black Gold to mellow it out...
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
That deer stuff is good
Crooner
November 01, 2018
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
This is my first blend I smoked with Deertongue it adds a sweetness to the Burley. The only thing I had to was let the blend air dry other wise I enjoyed the blend.
Dont be scared!
September 29, 2018
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner 2oz
One of my favs! don't let people scare you away from deertongue! tasty!!!!
Nothing to sing about
May 31, 2018
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
I have to qualify this by saying I am not much of a burley smoker. It tastes like cigarettes to me. So, if you like burley you might discount this review. Still, I have to say this wasn't bad for a burley. The cigarette taste was really subdued, and ... Read More
the deertongue had a nice vanilla tinge to it. Unfortunately, that is where things ended. If it had more to offer, I might have rated it higher. It was smooth, no tongue bite, and it smelled pleasant. It burned evenly and slow, but it came across as one-dimensional to me. Read Less
I'll let you know when my face heals.
March 29, 2018
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner 2oz
Picked up an ounce today just so I could try the deer tongue. Glad it was only an ounce. Upon first light I never wanted to get away from something so fast. The smoke was very harsh and acrid. My eyes started to burn and my nostrils started stinging ... Read More
like crazy. Just a really unpleasant first experience. But in the name of fair play I soldiered on. After the initial torching of my face this did settle down some.I can't say whether it was the deer tongue that caused it it to be so acrid or the burly. But in my experience Burly is usually pretty smooth. I could taste the faintly taste the vanilla of the deer tongue and I liked it, along with another herbal quality I couldn't put my finger on. My pipe went out so I lit up again. Same torching of the face and nostrils. I tried getting through it but called it quits. I've never done that with a pipe tobacco before. Besides the acrid smoke it actually smoked really cool. I've never been a cigarette smoker but I have smoked cigarettes on occasion. This was like finding a dried up crispy cigarette in your jacket and trying to smoke it. Just did not bring anything to the party. No complexity at all for me. Just tasted like burning. If Bing smoked this regularly he was The Man because I couldn't get through one bowl.
Pipe used: Savinelli Bulldog
Blend: Bulk Crooner from local tobacconist Read Less
Interesting
March 29, 2018
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
I'm not very well versed in burley blends as it stands but I'll still give my two cents. The burley is smooth, and has a cool smoke even if you heat it up pretty hot. I would say the nicotine hit is on the milder side of medium - enough to notice it ... Read More
but you don't feel yourself feeling it. The deer tongue is interesting to me. I get a light sweet vanilla-esque flavour on the retro-hale, but the actual mouth flavour is more akin to somewhere between natural and cough syrup cherry. It tastes like the smell of cherry juice from a fresh cherry, sweet with a sour side to it. Very mild, much milder than any aromatic, and it's certainly not unpleasant, just interesting. Not a regular smoke, but something nice to grab for a change of pace. Read Less
Buh-buh-buh-bummmm
December 10, 2017
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
This will have you crooning' for sure! This tobacco (as I smoke it) requires a smallish bowl packed very loosely. I love the deer tongue flavour and combined with the slightly nutty burley this burns very evenly and is very satisfying.
Recommended f... Read More
or sure. Flavour is enhanced when listening to Bing Crosby! Read Less
Tweeking
February 26, 2017
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
I'd like Crooner to have larger cubes. The current small cubes often get sucked down the air hole. Secondly, a bit more deerstongue would be good, more like it first was.
Go To Baccy!
February 14, 2017
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
I smoke two blends almost always. It's Crooner or my own latakia blend, made with C&D blending tobaccos. The majority of the time I smoke Crooner. I don't get any complaints about the aroma, but I would ignore them anyway. The cubes could be a little... Read More
larger, I get annoyed when I puff and get some tiny bits of tobacco I have to spit out. Read Less
A Pleasant Smoke
November 19, 2016
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
I am in the middle of my first pipeload of this burley blend, and it's pretty tasty. A little on the sweet side because of the deer tongue, but not like a full blown aromatic. It tastes kind of like mint minus the cooling sensation. I gravity loaded ... Read More
the bowl and tamped lightly after the char. It has burned like a champ. I can see myself smoking this on a regular basis, though it will never replace my favorites. Give it a shot if you're looking for something out of the ordinary.
Oh, and burned nice and clean to the bottom of the bowl. Be careful though. This stuff could cause ghosting problems. Use it in a cob or other disposable pipe until you decide whether you like it or not. Read Less
It's worth a try
September 05, 2016
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
I bought a oz to try and was very happy I did.If your a fan of strong burly then this one is for you. The deertounge added a taste that I can't really put my finger on but it's pleasant.And the nic-hit is very noticeable so sip this one slow.
Smoking a classic
July 02, 2016
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
The story behind this is singular as it is the experience. Smooth and tranquil smoke with the character of an exceptional burley. As the pale blue smoke dillutes it brings memories and conversation becomes transparent as well as your thoughts, concis... Read More
e.
Room note is said to be of a tobacco with subtle hints of vanilla that nevertheless are not present in the palate, which is more nutty and a bit spicy with very distant hints of something undetermined, perhaps floral.
Exceptional smoke, apt for any moment as all that is classic, Bing got it. Read Less
Pure nostalgia
May 17, 2016
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
Good pure burley flavor backed by the Carolina vanilla. A nice, simple, rustic style blend done right. Another C&D winner.
Impressive
December 25, 2015
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
I received 2 ounces of Crooner with a Savi Bing's Favorite for Christmas. I was impressed by the blend, very unique taste from the deertongue. Kind of a clovery honey-ish note. Definitely going to keep this in my blend rotation.
Not for the faint at heart
June 30, 2015
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
Smoking Bing's baccy is like driving an old classic car. It's all about the nostalgia. Hubba-bubba-bubba-boo...
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
I was really excited to try a blend with deertongue in it. Unfortunately, I find this blend to be a little bitter and flat. On the bright side, the smell from the pouch is awesome; the deertongue reminds me of something between vanilla and sweetgrass... Read More
, but it just doesn't smoke well for me. Too bad! Read Less
Croon A Piping Tune
February 19, 2015
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
Fantastic old world smoking pleasure all the way. Pair when listening to Bing's fine old chestnuts & watching Bing's classic films.
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
I ordered one oz
I love this at first opening of the pouch..the scent , so deep and evolving
I am a burnley fan and this is a wonderful smoke
so different and deep the aroma is this one.
I don't get any harshness at all as some say.
I will ord... Read More
er more.
for me so far ...is my favorite.
follow up....the only downside is it's ground up too much, like smoking pebbles ..so it's too dense in the pipe
and yes it's strong !! whew !!! Read Less
Pleasurable
September 08, 2014
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
Crooner can be strong,but if allowed to dry a bit and smoked slowly, it can be quite pleasurable. No comment on room note, as wife has had hay fever all summer. What I detect is very nice. It is an everyday smoke for me.I enjoy "different" tobaccos,... Read More
so if you want a run of the mill smoke, this isn't it. The vanilla,berry or cherry flavors are nice to me. Read Less
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
I have not tried many tobbaccos other than what you could easily find in most stores (Captain Black, Borkum Riff, etc) so dont know much about blends and such. Though I would give this one a try and for me is just no good. For me this is harsh ta... Read More
sing and almost unsmokable. Read Less
Product: Cornell & Diehl Crooner Bulk
I ordered 4 ozs which turned out to have a good amount of powdered residue from the bottom of the barrel. I strained some of the smaller pieces through a kitchen strainer. Thankfully, I recieved a credit for the purchase. What I could put in my pipe... Read More
s was a disappointment. This tobacco looks like small, round pellets. It has a high, harsh note which burns the tongue. I had to use multiple pipe cleaners to clear out clogging at the base of the chamber. I tried smoking this mixture in 3 different pipes and had the same experience with each. Unfortunately, I discarded it as unsmokable. . Read Less
Tobacco Pipes Search
|
|
Crooner 2oz
