Public Profile

D S.

Badges

Reviews

Cornell & Diehl - Manhattan Afternoon 2oz
could be better
i did not care for this blend. no real flavor, burned hot, wont stay lit for the first half of the bowl.i'm just not a fan of this one.

Rocky Patel - Java Mint X-Press (10 Pack)
java mint
over the years, i have smoker many a cigar. the java mint is the most satisfying i have ever found. i switched over to a pipe about 6 years ago, but every now and again, i grab one of my stash of java mints, light up and totally enjoy.

Sutliff - 500 African Queen
pleasant
I ordered this just to try something different. Glad i did, Smoked all i had, and ordered some more. The "english ' quality makes thia a fine smoke, to me..

Peterson - Sherlock Holmes 50g
smiles
a very quiet and delightful blend. burns smooth, tastes mild, great aroma. almost the best, so far

Daughters & Ryan - Three Sails
awful
burns quickly and hot, tastes like ground up old dried leaves. worst stuff i have ever ordered. cant win them all.

Sutliff - 1M
a surprise
i had this in my tobacco place and forgot about it. 3 days ago, i was going through my stash and found this 1M hidden away. Tried it out yesterday and it was just great. very satisfying taste, pleasant aroma, overall a really fine smoke. I'll get some more of this one.

Missouri Meerschaum - Drawdown 2oz
no thank you
a friend gave me this mix. he didn't like it. Smells ok in the tin, but after lighting, that stops! I don't care for it either. Just not flavorful at all. Just tasted like smoke.

Sutliff - #600 Mixture 79
not for me
terrible bite, burned hot, scent of burning wet weeds. No thanks.

Lane Limited - Black Raspberry
Black Raspberry
I found this blend to be tasteful, no tongue burn, smoked thoroughly, and a wonderful aroma that I've had other pipe smokers comment on several times. It's outstanding in a corncob, but I tried it in a meerschaum and wish I hadn't. Tha raspberry aroma really ghosts in that particular pipe. Still, it's a fine smoke.

Sutliff - Estate Blend
estate pipe tobacco
my opinion is far from others on this blend. I've been a pipe smoker for 61 years, and this is the WORST I've ever tried. Closer to dried tree bark. I'll give it one more shot, but can't be worse.

Sutliff - Frosty Mint
Not Bad At All
while i didn't find this blend quite as enchanting as described, it is still a pleasant smoke. I found a small to medium bowl better than a large one, it was a pleasant aroma, no bite, and a thorough burn. Pretty good stuff.

Peterson - Hyde Park 50g
Hyde Park
A totally delightful mid afternoon smoke. No bite, smooth burning. I honestly enjoyed this tobacco outside with my dog, Bentley the Beagle.

Kramer's - Blend for Cary Grant 50g
Fair
I got this in bulk and, while i was not displeased, i was not thrilled either. I found this blend "ho-hum". I may edit this after a few more bowls. Worth a try. 9/06 2024...never got better

Two Friends - English Chocolate 2oz
two friends plus me
a very pleasant, light smoking blend. Just enough latakia for my taste. Terrific aroma. A little dry, but stays fresh in the bowl. A mild tongue bite, but probably my own fault for drawing too quickly. I'm going to order more today.

Sutliff - D54 Chocolate Supreme
O.K.
puts me in mind of chocolate milk, without the milk.

Holger Danske - Black and Bourbon 50g
100%
truculentfrogs experience is exactly the same as mine. Harmonious and unique are just the right terms to use to describe this blend.

Edward G. Robinson - Edward G. Robinson's Pipe Blend 1.5oz
re review
when i first tried E.G.R. i was not too sure. The latakia overwhelmed me at that time. So I put it on the shelf to try again "later". Later came about a year later, I tried it again and was VERY satisfied. This time i truly enjoyed enjoyed it. I'm not a huge Latakia fan, even not, but this is a fine blend to me now. I'll get some more sometime soon.

Sir Walter Raleigh - Regular 7oz
surprised
This was a real treat for me. A little harsh, a mild bite, BUT smoked really well, stayed lit, smelled nice. All i could ask for and i'm pleased to have rediscovered it.

Warped - Until the End 2oz
not horrible
Gave this a try, I waited, it ended, I'm done. Not a bad smoke, but didn't really give me a thrill

Cornell & Diehl - Smooth English
uncharted
New territory for me. English blends have come to me slowly over time. Glad i tried this one. Wonderful aroma and mild on the tongue. Nice on a cold day

Sutliff - Z92 Vanilla Custard
nice, pleasant
A very nice and pleasant smoking experience. Sat outside,filled up, lit up, and enjoyed for an hour.

Lane Limited - TK-6
a miss
i always enjoy L.L.blends. Have for a long time. BUT this one is not to my liking. Bitter...or sour...and harsh. Might be great, but just not for me :( An update.....I've grown to enjoy this. It's really pretty good. Must have been a bad day when I wrote my other review.

Daughters & Ryan - Three Sails 16oz
not for me
i cant read oriental reviews, but if they say this is harsh, burns hot, tongue bites and overall unpleasant, then I agree.

Sutliff - 150 Mark Twain
Not too impressed
Just didn't care for it. aroma was ok but relight after relight, and a nasty tongue burn.

Ashton - Smooth Sailing 50g
It's O.K.
got as a gift, i appreciate the thought, but i found this very hard to pack, very hard to light, impossible to keep lit, and not really a good smoke. 2 stars because it smells nice in the tin.

Holger Danske - Mango and Vanilla 50g
Mango aand Vanilla
100% on the room note. A very pleasant smoke for any time of day.

Holger Danske - Black and Bourbon 50g
black and bourbon
A very fine blended, relaxing smoke that i prefer at the end on my day Even my Beagle, Bentley, enjoys this

Cornell & Diehl - Belmont Station
Belmont Station
A satisfying all day smoke. Little bite, and always enjoyable'

Cornell & Diehl - Haunted Bookshop
Nice Blend
A very nice blend of burleys. Fine aroma.

Low Country - Hazelnut
great stuff
I've been using this in my well seasoned corncob for about 3 weeks now. It's so smooth. A total delight. Stays lit and smokes to the bottom of the bowl. Give it a try.

Sutliff - Duke Albert
Very Fine Smoke
I found this to be a comfortable all day smoke. stays lit, a touch of tongue burn but not much, nice aroma. Pretty good stuff.

Cornell & Diehl - Autumn Evening
fine smoke
a very pleasant and enjoyable smoke. just right for a little while outside.

Mac Baren - 7 Seas Regular
7 Seas Regular
I use this as my change up. It's always satisfying. Relaxing.

Cornell & Diehl - Autumn Evening
Autum Evening
A very pleasant smoke. I find it best in a large bowl pipe. Burns gently and pleasant taste and aroma.

Gawith Hoggarth & Co. - Bob's Chocolate Flake 50g
Chocolate??
AWFUL. nice package, but the tobacco was horrible. did not smoke well, bad aroma, and left way too much oil goo in my pipe. Tried again, another day and different pipe.....same result. Smoke and learn. 9/13/23, I tried this two more times and ended up throwing it away. It's just not for me, I guess.

Cornell & Diehl - Smooth English
compare
I am a fan of Peterson stuff. Early Morning Pipe among my favorites. THIS blend is SO CLOSE that I've gone all in on it. A delicious mixture, very satisfying, and cheaper. Very good smoke.

Peterson - Sunset Breeze 50g
not too pleased
i opened a brand new tin of this yesterday. aroma was nice. BUT...DRY as dust. NO moisture whatsoever. very dissatisfied. Especially from a brand new, previously unopened tin. 9/23.... i moistened this tin (just a touch) and let it sit awhile. Better, but nothing to rave over. I'll finish this tin, because i bought it. After that, no more.

Sutliff - Dark and Silky 1.5oz
dark and silky
this looked like it could be fun, so i ordered one. when it arrived i opened him up tor a test run. Finished up, cleaned my pipe, went to the website and ordered 4 more so far. This is the one I must call my favorite. There are no mistakes here. A really big hit to me. It's the one smoke that I plan for. No calls, no mail, etc. Just me and my pipe. When I'm finished, all the worlds problem's are solved, and mind is cleared for the next several hours. THIS IS THE STUFF, for me. Can't define it, it just is 100% pleasure and relaxation. I've been a pipe smoker for over 50 years, tried all types of cuts and blends. But, having found this one, I'm done.

Ashton - Smooth Sailing 50g
nice gift
A friend of mine recently gave me a tin of this. unopened but several years old. I'v seen this several times, but never bought one. No reason, just didn't What a delightful surprise when i did. Fabulous aroma, a really great pipeful. burns slowly, a very relaxing smoke.Read the description for more details, This is REALLY nice stuff.

Sutliff - Dark and Silky 1.5oz
awesome stuff
my first try with this tobacco. I honestly cannot believe how great this is. Fantastic aroma, no tongue burn, wonderful flavor, and a VERY fine room note. Please try this. it's total satisfaction, in my opinion.

Mac Baren - 7 Seas Regular
strange occurance
I really enjoy this tobacco, smoke a pipeful almost every day. I smoke many different tobaccos, but only this one draws wasps to my deck. not to harm, they just fly around. And NO other tobacco does this. I guess wasps enjoy it as much as I do...…..9/13/23, the wasp thing is really strange. I have NO wasps at all until I smoke this blend. It's been happening all summer long and never fails. Amazing Just got through a hurricane. pleasant day, no bugs, nice breeze, even 2 hummingbirds. Sat out back, lit a pipeful of & seas, and out come the wasps again. They sure do love this stuff!!!!!!!!!!!

Granger - Granger 7oz
granger
Not a bad tobacco, a little dry, a little harsh, but still not a bad smoke

Gifts - Smokingpipes Coffee Mug (Black)
My mug
Top quality. Heavy and beautiful.

Cornell & Diehl - Crooner
Just For Fun
I recently acquired a Savinelli Bing Crosby pipe and ordered this tobacco just to try in this pipe. It's not the best tobacco but I smoke the pipe and this tobacco when I'm golfing. I should stop playing golf and just go home and enjoy my pipe!

Sir Walter Raleigh - Regular 7oz
Great Old Timer
Many years have gone by since I last tried S.W.R. Why I ever gave this up is a mystery to me. Not harsh, smokes down to ash, no bite and very pleasant aroma. Can't do much better that that.

Mac Baren - 7 Seas Regular
7 Seas Regular
I have become very fond of this one. I must agree with Scott S. A fine all-day smoke. "Good Stuff".....9/2023, still enjoy this one. One of my regulars.

Mac Baren - Symphony
not good
Dry as a bone right out of the package. Harsh, NO flavor whatsoever, will NOT stay lit. Worst I have ever tried in 53 years of pipe smoking.

Cornell & Diehl - Billy Budd
Billy Budd
I'v been looking for this for 53 years. As soon as I lit a lit a bowlful, it made me smile. Finally found precisely the taste and aroma I wanted. This is sublime.